[FFmpeg-devel] [RFC] the future of libamr
Sat Jun 6 20:20:09 CEST 2009
Diego Biurrun wrote:
> On Fri, Jun 05, 2009 at 02:21:23PM +0100, Robert Swain wrote:
>> OK, then I guess the only issue is a feature regression in that
>> libopencore-amrwb doesn't do encoding. As Diego points out, there's
>> nothing stopping people from using FFmpeg 0.5 or a version of svn from
>> before the libamr reference wrapper gets removed, but I'm not really
>> fond of feature regressions. Is there any good reason not to keep the
>> libamr-wb reference encoder wrapper?
> May I suggest that you read the 25+ messages in this thread before
> restarting the discussion at square one? Pros and cons have already
> been hashed out extensively and a consensus seemed to have been reached.
> If you have anything new to add, reply to the relevant subthread. Just
> raising the same concerns over and over again is inconstructive and
> leads nowhere.
I had actually read them but had forgotten about them as I was out of
the country so, I apologise for this. However, I didn't see a deadline
set for consensus to be reached.
Benoit had some reservations about feature regression then decided it
was OK, though I don't see him mention any compelling reason why he
changed his mind other than that removing non-free components is good.
Then Baptiste commented that he wasn't too keen on a feature regression
and you stated that it seemed a consensus had been reached. Then 3 days
after Baptiste's comment, you committed the OpenCORE support and said
you were going to remove libamr. A consensus has not been reached if not
everyone has accepted the same idea and it seems not everyone has.
I'm not sure how many people actually use AMR-WB encoding. I would guess
the parties interested would be mostly commercial.
I don't really know what option is best. It's non-free but removing it
would be a feature regression. Why did we have the AMR reference
implementation wrapped in the first place if not having non-free stuff
in FFmpeg was a major concern versus not having the feature?
More information about the ffmpeg-devel